Painting Contest 2

[Varaj]

Phil Winslade vs Patrick Woodroffe

[FeatsofClay]

Ouch!

Number 2 for subject matter and number 1 for painting excellence!

I can comment but not choose. :)

[The Winslow]

Woodroffe's composition and graphical style is more appealing. In a way, the first reminds me of the art pompier, overblown and pretentious.

[Xavier Lang]

I don't like the stars or facial expressions in Winslade's.

[Harry]

In a contest between comic book heroes and sad clowns, I'll take the comic book heroes, thank you very much.

[doc]

My eye was drawn to Winslade's painting

[Black Angel]

I did like the colours in Winslade, but it seemed very static, so I'll have to pick Woodroffe for having more personality.

[Dr_Avalanche]

I don't like the composition in the first one at all, so Woodroffe.